These stoner questions are exactly what the internet loves to debate — the divisive, ridiculous, and surprisingly philosophical “this or that” dilemmas that hit different when you are already a few bowls in. The host of Herbistry420 stumbled onto a website full of these during a solo session and decided to record his uncensored answers live. Here is the breakdown, with a few thoughts to help you decide where you land on each one.
Stoner Questions: The Internet’s Most Divisive Dilemmas
The first batch of stoner questions covers the classics: pineapple pizza or candy corn, winning the lottery or finding your soulmate, and the eternal glass-half-full-or-half-empty debate. The host picks pineapple pizza over candy corn without hesitation, the lottery over a soulmate (a shift driven by age and realism), and glass half full as a deliberate mindset practice. These stoner questions reveal more about your priorities than you might expect — which is exactly what makes them fun to answer out loud with people you actually know.
This or That Game: Rules and How It Works
The this or that game is simple: two options are presented and you must pick one — no fence-sitting, no hybrid answers. The host sourced the question set from a website that curates hundreds of these “would you prefer” scenarios ranked by how divisive they are. The format works perfectly as a this or that game to run during a smoke session because the real entertainment begins when people disagree and have to defend their picks. There are no wrong answers, but there are definitely funnier ones, and the debates are where the magic happens.
What Would You Prefer Game: Philosophical Picks
The what would you prefer game gets genuinely interesting once the questions move past food debates into bigger life questions. Zombies vs vampires: vampire wins — stay sharp and party through the centuries versus shuffling around hungry and braindead. Air guitar vs air drums: depends on the song — Phil Collins “In the Air Tonight” makes air drums unavoidable for everyone in the room. Rich and famous or rich and unknown: unknown but respected for your craft. These what would you prefer game prompts work because they force a commitment and an explanation, which surfaces what you actually value when you strip away social politeness.
Lets Play a Game Stoned: Best Session Questions
When you lets play a game stoned with your crew, start with the food questions to warm up (pineapple pizza, guacamole vs salsa) and work toward the heavier ones. The robots vs dinosaurs question lands especially well post-ChatGPT — there is now a statistically higher chance of a robot affecting your future than a velociraptor chasing you through the jungle, which gives it an unintentional layer of commentary. The phone-in-the-bathroom question works as a nostalgia trigger: before smartphones, people read shampoo bottles and old magazines back-to-back. The best time to lets play a game stoned is when you have a mixed group — the varying answers make for the longest debates.
Stoner Game Questions: Full List from the Video
The complete set of stoner game questions from the video: pineapple pizza or candy corn, winning the lottery or finding your soulmate, glass half full or half empty, phone in the bathroom or no phone, zombies or vampires, air guitar or air drums, robots or dinosaurs, guacamole or salsa, boxers or briefs, and rich and famous or rich and unknown. These stoner game questions are posted in the YouTube description in full — copy them into the comments with your own answers to start the debate. The host invites viewers to share their picks, and the comment section is a genuinely entertaining read.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best stoner questions from this video?
The zombie vs vampire question kicks off the most philosophical tangent. Robots vs dinosaurs hits differently now that AI has changed the risk landscape. Boxers vs briefs is the most personal pick — the answer is boxer briefs, a diplomatic solution to an unnecessary question. All 10 are listed in the video description.
How does the this or that game work with a group?
One person reads the question out loud, everyone picks simultaneously (no peeking at other answers first), then the group reveals and debates. Works best with 3-6 people. Sessions tend to run longer than expected because even straightforward questions like guacamole vs salsa can spiral into twenty-minute food debates when everyone is sufficiently stoned.
Is the what would you prefer game better stoned?
Consistently yes. The cannabis mindset tends to slow down the snap judgment and make people actually think about why they prefer one option over the other. The lottery vs soulmate question, for instance, takes a very different form at 21 versus at 40 — and when stoned, that reflection tends to come out more honestly.
Where do I find questions to lets play a game stoned?
The host sourced from a website that ranks this-or-that questions by how divisive they are online. The full list from the video is in the YouTube description. You can also search “this or that questions” to find generators with hundreds of options sorted by category — pop culture, food, life preferences, and absurdist scenarios.
What makes these stoner game questions good for groups?
The best stoner game questions have no objectively correct answer and are easy to have a strong opinion about. Food choices (pineapple pizza, guacamole) create quick, passionate disagreements. Life questions (lottery vs soulmate) create longer, more thoughtful discussions. Mixing both types across a session keeps the energy varied and prevents the game from stalling.
References
Learn More on Herbistry420
Purchase Links
Support Herbistry420 by visiting our Cannabis Apparel Store, we have t-shirts, hoodies, pants, towels, you name it!
Note: Some links are affiliate links. Purchases through these links support the channel at no extra cost to you.
Add comment